EnglishOpinionPolitics

Shock Doctrine as Governance Ideology in Ethiopia

Unpacking Prosperity Party’s Package of Pragmatism 

Shock Doctrine as Governance Ideology in Ethiopia: Unpacking Prosperity Party’s Package of Pragmatism 

Girma Gutema (Abbaacabsaa)

Background

The term “Shock Doctrine” as a coinage is associated with the Canadian author, social activist and filmmaker Naomi Klein. Klein popularized the term through her influential book titled The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism. In this seminal work, she defines the strategy of ‘Shock Doctrine’ as an ideological adventure in which political actors, specifically those who controlled state powers, exploit the chaos created by civil wars, internal conflicts, natural disasters and other crises to push through unpopular policies such as market deregulation, centralization and privatization of public properties.

The ideological doctrine drives the economic interests of corporate powers at the expense of the marginalized, the disadvantaged and the disenfranchised mass of citizens. And, regimes which espouse such policies implement them when the mass of the citizenry are too distracted, disoriented and overwhelmed to put effective resistance against such bad policies.

Manufacturing chaos and confusions has always remained at the heart of the mainstream politics in such an ideologically adventurous model of governance. The aim of this article is to explore how the ruling Prosperity Party regime in Ethiopia is trying to espouse and appropriate The Shock Doctrine as an ideological framework, not to say a creed, to govern this complex country with a lingering imperial legacy of conflicts and contestations including on history.

Unpacking Prosperity Party’s ideology: Shock Doctrine or Pragmatism?

The Prosperity Party (PP) regime in power in Ethiopia today claims no clear political ideology to which it subscribes. Often times, it asserts that “pragmatism” is a political mechanism that it employs to govern this very complex country using some raw ideas thatched together in the book Medemer, written by Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed. Pragmatism IS NOT, and CAN NOT be, a political ideology. Neither is a “Prosperity Gospel”, as some say—though this constitutes part of the official nomenclature of the party anyhow. It would therefore be imperative to unpack as to what the real ideology of this ruling party of the current regime in Ethiopia could certainly be.

Practical cases that happened over the last seven years of Prosperity Party’s rule in Ethiopia show that the anchoring political ideology of the regime has been The Shock Doctrine. Who imagined, even remotely, that this Prosperity Party regime would open such devastating civil wars in and/or against the three largest and most important states within the Ethiopian multinational federation—Oromia, Tigray and Amhara? These three regional states account for a staggering 85% of the population and about 70% of Ethiopia’s geographic land mass.

Nevertheless, such reckless adventures of the regime served only to promote and normalize:

  1. The trivialization of the destruction, the death and of human dignity;
  2. The de-sensitization of all human sufferings, including those happening due to difficulties associated with economic, political and social problems driven by the shocking policies of the regime.

With an urban area focused project it called “Corridor Development Project”, the Prosperity Party regime undertook massive demolitions of residential homes, river and roadside shops and other small and large scale business facilities in major urban centers across Ethiopia except in Tigray state. Such massive destruction of peoples’ properties involved the demolition of entire units of urban administrative districts in cities like Finfinne/Addis (e.g Kazanchis & Doro Manekia/Piazza), and partial areas in cities in Oromia like Adama, Jimma and Bishoftu.

What’s more, only the war in Tigray, for which we got estimate data on all kinds of casualty figures of up to 1million deaths and 1.5 displacements, is said to be the largest and the most destructive of all the wars in the twenty first century. In fact, the number of people killed in this war exceeds all the major wars that were fought in the history of the modern Ethiopian state combined, including in the war with fascist Italy at Adwa in 1896.

As to the trivialization of human dignity, it’s certainly under the current PP regime that Ethiopians have had to endure watching, pictures and footages on social media, such mentally shocking and physically chilling happenings and events including the coldblooded killings of popular Oromo artists like Hachalu Hundessa and Batte Urgessa. The dead bodies of citizens killed by regime security agents happened to be de-dignified through such savagery and inhumane actions as loading packs of human dead bodies on the back of donkeys. Can anything become more shocking than these in our society, thanks to the ‘Shock Doctrine’ ideology of the regime?

Reports of human suffering and death including those happening due to economic and social difficulties driven by regime’s misguided policies have long turned daily routines in our society, so much so that the general population became de-sensitized to them. The cumulative effect of all these trivialization of the destructions, mass atrocity crimes as well as the de-sensitization to all human sufferings created acute fear, disorientation and confusion among the general public—these all being among the key objectives of Shock Doctrine as a political ideology. This unfortunate state of affairs in turn dictated not only desperate individuals and families in the society who are directly affected by the shock of this Shock Doctrine ideology, but it also influenced the wider populace to at least temporarily seek and settle on a sort of survivalist mode. And this is the general condition we have in the country today, and it came to be precisely due to the Shock Doctrine that the ruling Prosperity Party is employing as its political ideology.

The Legacy of Shock Doctrine as Governing Ideology

The legacy of Shock Doctrine as a governing ideology elsewhere in the world can better be linked to no other than the controversial legacy of “The Chicago Boys” of the 1970s. As Naomi Klein also argues in her book, the origin and legacy of the Shock Doctrine as a governing ideology is located in the Latin American counties of the 1970s. Chile was the first country in that part of the world which implemented this Shock Doctrine ideology through a small group of powerful elite educated at the department of economics, University of Chicago, in the United States. This group of very few men, who would later come to be known as “The Chicago Boys” implemented the Shock Doctrine after overthrowing a democratically elected leftist president Salvador Allende, thereby establishing a military dictatorship headed by General Augusto Pinochet. Some of “The Chicago Boys” who become cabinet ministers of the dictatorial military government then went on to design and implement neoliberal economic policies anchored on the ideals of the Shock Doctrine that can only be put into practice at the gun point.

The Shock Doctrine as a political ideology turned out to be a pattern in the Latin American countries of the 1970s, as military rules that normalized systemic murders and torture swept into power, thereby essentially cementing some of the ugliest legacies of the Chicago Boys. The trend took several years to be reversed by grass roots democratic movements that deposed those systems of dictatorships.

As Ms Klein also convincingly argues in her aforementioned book, institutions such as the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and The World Bank (WB) had gained considerable leverage by the 1980s because of the massive debt burden under which most “Third World Countries” were struggling. A structural adjustment packages rooted in the absurd neoliberal economic models were prescribed as a singular and most potent medicine which can cure all the diseases of economic, social and political origins everywhere in the world.

In my opinion, members of Ethiopia’s ruling Prosperity Party and its ‘trained economists’ like my own town boy from Negelle Borena, Ahmed Shide (not to say my old good friend), Eyob Tekalign (PhD) and Mamo Mihretu (this one seems to have no credible background in economic science or common sense though) are the ones who incarnate ‘The Chicago Boys’ of Ethiopia today—for the better or worse. The PP regime not only espoused this absurd ideology of Shock Doctrine with the guise of “pragmatism”, but it also took the ugliest face of this ideology to a whole new level unprecedented elsewhere in the world. The ruling elite especially those at the top echelon of the power hierarchy do not seem to care about the sufferings of the mass of the population as they forcefully continue pushing on with this destructive ideology. They are doing everything to shove it down into the throats of the poor, the disenfranchised and the severely suffering Ethiopians. But ultimately, their pursuit of this cruel and dangerously destructive policy can be halted only when all those who bear the brunt of its bone-breaking consequences rise up in unison, thereby forcing the regime to stop pushing the country on the edge.

Editor’s Note: Girma Gutema is an independent researcher and human rights defender based in Oromia, Ethiopia. He is member of the opposition Oromo Federalist Congress (OFC). He tweets @Abbaacabsa

Show More

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

five × 3 =

Back to top button
Copy link